MAY 2, 2025
Yogurt vs. Greek Yogurt: What are the Benefits, and Why They Belong in Your Smoothie
Greek or regular yogurt — which one wins in your smoothie? Find out which packs more protein, less sugar, and why it’s your new secret weapon.
Read time: 10 minutes
When it comes to yogurt, it’s having its moment to shine. Walk down the dairy aisle and it feels like you're stepping into a high-end boutique: full-fat, non-fat, Icelandic-style, Greek, drinkable, dairy- free, fruit-on-the-bottom, protein-packed, even dessert-y versions. It’s a lot.
But today, we’re cutting through the confusion and focusing in on two in particular: regular yogurt and Greek yogurt. We’ll break down what’s actually in them — carbs, fat, protein, vitamins, minerals — and why yogurt (especially Greek yogurt) might be the secret weapon you’re missing in your day, especially when you throw it in a smoothie.
First Things First: What’s the Difference Between Yogurt and Greek Yogurt?
They both start the same way: milk + live cultures = yogurt.
But Greek yogurt goes one step further. After the milk ferments and thickens, Greek yogurt is strained — a lot. This straining process removes much of the liquid whey, lactose (milk sugar), and water. What you’re left with is a thicker, creamier, tangier yogurt that’s packed with more protein and less sugar.
Think of Greek yogurt as yogurt’s swole cousin who spends a lot of time at the gym.
Let’s Break It Down: Nutrition Face-Off
Protein
- Regular yogurt: ~5–9g per 6 oz serving
- Greek yogurt: ~15–20g per 6 oz serving
Greek yogurt dominates here. The straining process concentrates the protein, which makes it awesome for keeping you full, preserving muscle, and powering your day — especially in the morning or post-workout.
Carbs & Sugar
- Regular yogurt: ~12–20g carbs per 6 oz (can be more if sweetened)
- Greek yogurt: ~5–10g carbs per 6 oz
Greek yogurt has way fewer carbs (mostly lactose) thanks to the straining. If you're watching your sugar, this makes a big difference. Just beware: many flavored yogurts — even Greek ones — sneak in a ton of added sugars. Always check the label.
Fat
- Non-fat: 0g fat
- Low-fat: ~2g fat
- Whole milk: ~5g fat
Both yogurts come in all fat levels. Don’t fear the full-fat! That little bit of fat can help you feel satisfied longer, and it helps your body absorb fat-soluble vitamins like A and D.
Vitamins & Minerals
Here’s where both kinds of yogurt shine.
- Calcium: ~15–20% of your daily value (bone health superstar)
- B12: great for energy and brain function
- Phosphorus: works with calcium for strong bones
- Riboflavin (B2): helps your body turn food into fuel
- Probiotics: live cultures that help support gut health
Greek yogurt sometimes has slightly less calcium because of the straining, but it's still solid.
So, Why Should You Care?
Yogurt — especially Greek yogurt — is more than a breakfast food or a side snack. It’s basically a nutrition cheat code. You’re getting protein, calcium, gut-friendly bacteria, and it plays well with both sweet and savory flavors.
And one of the easiest, most delicious ways to work it into your day? Smoothies.
Yogurt in Smoothies: The Secret Sauce
You could make a smoothie with just fruit and ice, sure. But if you want something that actually sticks with you — add Greek yogurt.
Here’s why:
It Adds Creaminess Without Ice Cream
Greek yogurt makes your smoothie silky-smooth and thick without needing sugary frozen yogurt or dairy creamer. It’s rich and luscious, but way healthier.
It Supercharges the Protein
Fruit-based smoothies alone won’t give you much protein. A scoop of Greek yogurt adds 15+ grams instantly — perfect for post-workout recovery or keeping your afternoon hunger at bay.
It Balances the Sugar
Fruit = sugar (even if it’s natural). Greek yogurt’s protein slows digestion and helps prevent blood sugar spikes and crashes. That means longer-lasting energy — not a sugar high and crash an hour later.
It Supports Your Gut
The probiotics in yogurt help your digestive system stay in balance. Bonus: a healthy gut may also support your immune system and even affect your mood. Wild, right?
Smoothie Idea: Greek Yogurt Power Shake
Here’s a go-to recipe that tastes amazing and actually fills you up.
It Supports Your Gut
- 1/2 cup frozen blueberries
- 1 small banana (or half, if you’re watching sugar)
- 3/4 cup plain Greek yogurt
- 1/2 cup almond milk or milk of choice
- 1 tablespoon almond butter or peanut butter
- Dash of cinnamon or a splash of vanilla
- Handful of spinach (you won’t taste it, promise)
- Ice, if you like it extra cold
Blend it all together. Boom — creamy, dreamy, and packed with nutrition.
Bottom Line: Greek Yogurt = Simple Superfood
Whether you’re spooning it straight, layering it in a parfait, or blending it into a smoothie, yogurt is a seriously smart food choice. And Greek yogurt in particular is a game-changer for anyone who wants to:
- Eat more protein without a ton of meat
- Stay full between meals
- Support gut health
- Make smoothies that are actually satisfying
Just be mindful of what you’re buying. Go for plain, unsweetened, and full-fat or low-fat, depending on your needs. Add your own fruit and honey if you want a bit of sweetness — at least then you control the sugar.
Suggested Products:
Written by Matthew Stogdon
Matt is a seasoned writer with 20 years of experience, leveraging understanding of fitness as a former rugby player and his insight from covering contact sports.